Joey Barton says Alex Scott 'shouldn't comment on men's football'

Joey Barton says Alex Scott ‘shouldn’t comment on men’s football’ in a direct attack on the BBC’s punditry golden girl… as former Sky Sports commentator Bianca Westwood takes him to task over sexist comments

  • Joey Barton has claimed pundit Alex Scott shouldn’t discuss men’s football  
  • The controversial star has come under fire for his comments about women   
  • IAN LADYMAN reveals the GREATEST weapon a manager has against a journalist – Listen to It’s All Kicking Off 

Joey Barton has claimed Alex Scott ‘shouldn’t comment on men’s football’ as he continued his tirade on women’s involvement in the male arena.

The former Bristol Rovers boss and ex-Man City player has come under fire for his controversial posts about female broadcasters and pundits this week, having tweeted that women ‘shouldn’t be talking with any kind of authority in the men’s game’. 

After his words generated huge outrage online, he was invited onto Piers Morgan’s show on TalkTV, where he doubled down on this thoughts, hitting out at the ‘woke agenda’ and said the world was ‘going crazy’ due to the uptick in female presenters.

And his rant also saw him take aim at BBC’s golden girl Scott, who is one of the leading female pundits in football and the host of the popular Football Focus show. She has also appeared as a regular face on Match of the Day and Sky Sports.  

When asked about Scott commentating on men’s games, Barton said: ‘She hasn’t played in it’. 

Joey Barton has claimed Alex Scott ‘shouldn’t comment on men’s football’ as he continued his rants about women’s involvement in the men’s game

Your browser does not support iframes.

He added: ‘One is 200 years old and one is about 40 years old… it’s the same rules but football is about a lot more than rules… The games are at two different speeds.

‘I don’t care where you’re from or how many games you’ve played, but you have to have a body of work that is credible to get you there… the world has gone crazy.’

He had earlier responded to a fan quizzing him about Scott’s credentials as a pundit, saying: ‘Fantastic women’s footballer. Decorated in her game. If she’s presenting a men’s game, no problem, anchor the show. But, no, she isn’t qualified to talk with any authority about the men’s game in my opinion.’ 

On Morgan’s show, Barton explained that he did not want to be seen promoting sexism, but that he was against ‘unqualified opinions’.

‘I don’t want to see sexism in football, but if we don’t debate (the role of women in football broadcasting) properly, this is just going to rise and rise, and ruin the experience of watching elite-level men’s football,’ Barton said when asked by Morgan if the language of his social media posts had been deliberately inflammatory.

‘Everywhere you turn now, there’s an unqualified opinion pontificating about the sport I love, and it’s ruining my experience – to fuel this woke agenda, and it’s going to increase sexism massively, because it has to be a true meritocracy. We have to have people who are qualified to do those roles.’

The former Premier League footballer sparked fresh controversy after hitting out at women being given jobs in men’s football

When prompted on why he didn’t feel women were qualified, Barton stressed that it was ‘absolutely not about’ women having not played at the top level of the men’s game.

Instead, he argued, he was against ‘tokenism’ before adding: ‘Obviously it helps to talk about the men’s game if you’ve played at a higher level, because it gives you a unique experience.’

‘There’s a lot of similarities between both sports, but the men’s game is played at a completely different speed, with a different skillset needed. For someone to stand there and say ‘I would have done this’, or ‘He’s made a mistake’ – who have no experience of that…

‘It’s not just one or two, it (football broadcasting has) been taken over.

‘I don’t want to come across as sexist, I’ve got a wonderful wife, wonderful daughter, grandmother.

Barton doubled down on his controversial views while making an appearance on Piers Morgan: Uncensored on Thursday evening

‘We want it to be diverse and inclusive, but it’s got to be credible.’

After his one-to-one with Morgan, Barton was then joined by Sky Sports presenter Bianca Westwood, as well as female sports hosts Kait Borsay and Pearl Davis.

Westwood decided to take him to task on his view that women weren’t qualified.  

‘Who is qualified to speak on football then? I’ve been watching football for 40 years, my first game at West Ham was before Joey was even born.

‘I’ve been watching hours and hours of football,’ she said. ‘I worked behind the scenes at Sky for 10 years before I was even given a shot on camera, watching my male colleagues who maybe weren’t as good as I was, getting chances I was never given.

‘I don’t really understand what we need to know, how long we need to work behind the scenes before we are allowed on camera. To be a pundit, the laws are the same. Emma Hayes and Sarina Wiegman can both read the game, are you saying they can’t offer an insight?

Sky Sports presenter Bianca Westwood later took Barton to task on his claim that women were unqualified to speak on the men’s game

‘Sounds like to me that Joey has a problem with particular pundits who haven’t done enough in the game, but how does he know? And how do we quantify that? There’s EFL players who are commentating, co-commentating on Champions League games. So what level – as far as Joey Barton is concerned – do you have to get before you can be an expert on the ‘men’s game’?’

It was Barton’s initial tweet that caused outrage, insisting he ‘couldn’t take a thing they say serious’ if it’s in the men’s arena. 

‘Women shouldn’t be talking with any kind of authority in the men’s game. Come on. Let’s be serious.

‘It’s a completely different game. If you don’t accept that. We will always see things differently.

‘The women’s game is thriving. Fantastic to see. I cannot take a thing they say serious in the men’s arena.’

Barton has previously thrown his support behind the #HERGAMETOO initiative – which aims to fight against sexism in sport

Barton’s posts come after he had previously thrown his support behind the #HERGAMETOO initiative.

This is a campaign which aims to fight against sexism in sport, with Barton posing with a promotional card for the cause when he was Bristol Rovers manager. 

Back in October, he also generated controversy after sharing his apparent backing for former Newcastle and England manager Kevin Keegan’s comments that he doesn’t enjoy female footballers talking about men’s football.

At a live event in Bristol, Keegan had said: ‘(I don’t like) listening to ladies talking about the England men’s team at the match because I don’t think it’s the same experience. I have a problem with that.’

In response to that, Barton had posted on X: ‘Kevin Keegan. Ballon D’or winner 1978. England manager. He’s bang on.’

His remarks also come just a week after he appeared to downplay his brother Michael Barton’s role in a 2005 racially-motivated murder as a ‘f***ing scrap’.

A promotional clip for Barton’s appearance on a new podcast appeared to show him downplay his brother’s role in the racially-motivated killing of Anthony Walker

Barton was playing for Manchester City when Michael was convicted of murdering Anthony Walker, with his brother serving 17 years of a life sentence for his part in killing the black 18-year-old in McGoldrick Park in Liverpool before being released from prison in September 2022.

Barton appeared to play down the severity of his brother’s crime in promotional material for his appearance on the podcast Anything Goes with James English which circulated on social media on Thursday. 

‘My brother lost 17 years of his life from 17,’ Barton said. ‘Because his mate who was his cousin at the time thought it would be a fantastic idea when they were having a f***ing scrap to pull an ice axe out, and swing it into somebody, and he’s stuck it into somebody’s head.’

A statement shared by the Anthony Walker Foundation with Mail Sport stated that they considered the description ‘factually inaccurate’ and ‘lacking in any sensitivity given the serious nature of the incident’. 


It’s All Kicking Off is an exciting new podcast from Mail Sport that promises a different take on Premier League football, launching with a preview show today and every week this season.

It is available on MailOnline, Mail+, YouTube , Apple Music and Spotify

Your browser does not support iframes.

Source: Read Full Article